While you take the time to read this article (and I sincerely hope you do), someone somewhere in the world is buying or selling stolen art. Every day is another opportunity for the thieves to increase their wealth while unscrupulous collectors add another work to their possessions.
The arts as represented especially by paintings and sculpture top the list of things most easily stolen and sold underground to collectors. I wish we didn’t have to refer to them as collectors because I would prefer to call them criminal collectors. Or maybe just criminals. They shouldn’t be respected by calling them collectors. They seem to live by their own rules with little concern for the long term consequences of their criminal activities.
Simon Houpt wrote The Museum of the Missing, about stolen artwork, in 2006. The book begins with a foreword by Julian Radcliffe, the chairman of the Art Loss Register, a world-wide organization based in London. The Register maintains a database of stolen artwork that is continually updated. Radcliffe notes, “Art theft has become a global problem.” He says, “IT is a crime that affects all of us. Nearly half of all items recovered by the Art Loss Register are found outside the country where they were stolen. Great amounts of money are involved, there are links to organized crime, and the lost pieces of our cultural heritage are irreplaceable.”
Mr. Houpt posits the theory that politicians are reluctant to spend money on retrieving the stolen items because most people don’t place a high priority on recovery. If people are ignorant of their heritage and history, they are not likely to think about the ramifications of the theft of art. As fewer schools teach classes in art and music, as the study of history is watered down or distorted all out of recognition of the truth, people are not exposed to the importance of cultural items and historical significance. This is not the article for a diatribe on the curriculum of public schools, although what is taught does affect the attitudes people develop at an early age.
Meyer de Haans Self Portrait
The question for us to examine is why is there so much art theft? Art has become the currency du jour of the criminal underworld and terrorist groups. Art is easier to obtain (by stealing, naturally) than diamonds. Most of it can be made portable by cutting the paintings out of their frames and rolling them up or packing them into shipping cartons with other items. Art work can be held in escrow while transactions are being completed or stored safely in numerous places. Naturally the stolen work escapes the roving eyes of tax collectors so there will never be a public record of art for cash or weapons or what have you.
The fact that art prices have risen astronomically, to say the very least, makes all thefts that much more tempting. When the Masterpieces of art fetch millions of dollars, people are much more willing to take extraordinary risks to obtain that work. Ergo, art has become a commodity not unlike pork belly futures. (I couldn’t resist a silly comparison in an attempt to lighten up!) Art for dollars, or something more nefarious. A new methodology entered the criminal world.
Art thefts and sales weren’t invented in the 20th century, of course. But the idea of trading a stolen Picasso or Caravaggio for a shipment of weapons brought a new seriousness and sinister atmosphere to the trades. It also brought in a higher level of policing. Stolen goods were one thing; swapping stolen art for Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles or fissionable material was a completely different situation. Now the intelligence services and security services joined the local constabulary in trying to find, track and capture the thieves, dealers, buyers and anyone else involved in the supply chain.
As Sherlock Holmes would say, the game is afoot. And it has become quite the game of risk worldwide. There does not seem to be any preventive measure to dissuade the thieves, so the loss prevention must happen at the site of the artwork. Sadly, that has been ineffectual, as we will explore next week.